Since when did 'perfect smokey eye' become an insult, America?

Comedian Michelle Wolf was slammed by a wide range of commentators for commenting on the press secretary’s eye shadow. ‘She burns facts and then she uses that ash to create a perfect smokey eye. If you’re not familiar with the common parlance of cosmetics, you might not know that ‘a perfect smokey eye’ is a very nice way to describe a woman’s makeup – glamorous, well-applied, nicely smudged.